Tiger Aspect Holdings Ltd leased some offices in London’s Soho Square. The lease included terms to ensure they did various repair works while they were there. However, once the lease expired and Tiger had left the building, the landlord, Sunlife Europe Properties Ltd, found the premises were in poor condition.
In order to re-let the property, the landlord had to carry out extensive works. They then sued Tiger to recover the cost of the works. Here’s what happened next.
Both parties briefed specialist valuers to produce reports about the value of the property – this is not the role of a solicitor, although we are increasingly asked for our view on what works are required and who should be liable.
The judge looked at the following issues:
The tenant should have returned the premises in ‘good and tenantable repair and condition, and with the mechanical and electrical systems in satisfactory working order’. According to the lease, Tiger did not have to replace the lift or air conditioning with new apparatus, as long as the existing equipment still worked.
In this case, the landlord decided to re-render the façade of the building to make it more attractive. They would have done this even if Tiger had left it in good repair, so this was not included in the judgement.
This area is known as ‘dilapidations’, and covers many detailed and difficult points of law. This is where a commercial property solicitor is indispensable.
Disputes like this can sometimes be resolved using Professional Arbitration on Court Terms (PACT). Rather than depending on a judge with legal expertise, the Law Society of Royal Institute of Chartered Surveyors will appoint an arbitrator who may be a building surveyor with professional expertise in buildings.
Some questions for you to consider…
Venetia Lawson-Cruttenden [solicitor] is fantastic! She is always so thorough and efficient and gives you the
DG Law supported us through a very difficult contractual negotiation to achieve exactly the outcome
We were very pleased with the way that DG Law helped us on our transaction
Thanks for all the help from DG Law in pulling together our somewhat complicated loan.
DG Law resolved a difficult lease renewal for us and their services were excellent –
I needed understanding and experienced legal advice. DG Law provided an excellent service at a
My experience was second to none – the service was professional and personal. DG Law
DG Law always step up to the plate on our transactions and handle the various
DG Law was recommended to me and my partner and I received excellent advice –
Having worked with DG Law a number/couple of times now, I have been really impressed
DG Law were constantly at hand, and kept pro-active throughout the thorny process of getting
DG Law organised and ran a very useful session to help to make our team’s
DG Law came recommended to me and whilst setting up a new business it was
We were recommended three lawyers to handle the sale of our seven year old successful
We live by our core values of transparency, flexibility and being honourable – every day
We put ourselves in your shoes so we understand your problems from the inside out
We deliver our advice in a way that is easy to understand